When we were asked to review the BabyPlus Prenatal Education System, we decided to cautiously accept the sample. Just because it’s not our cup of tea doesn’t mean our readers don’t want our honest opinion about it, right?
The “system” is essentially a bag you wear around your waist/belly (like a fanny pack - I love that word) that plays “A series of 16 scientifically designed sounds that resemble a mother’s heartbeat.” It’s designed to be worn starting at about 18 weeks, when baby’s hearing is functional, until 32 weeks. My first thought was that it’s similar to playing music for your unborn child, which is fabulous whether it has any effect on brain development at all simply because it connects you for your baby and starts exposing him to the tunes you’ll be irritating him with until he leaves for college.
My problem with this product is with the use of the words “curriculum” & “lessons” in regard to a fetus. Hello? Aren’t kids forced into planned formal education early enough? It’s bad enough we don’t just let them learn through play when they’re toddlers & preschoolers, but now we’re starting before they’re even born? Slightly ridiculous if you ask me. My husband laughed out loud when he saw this product, as did everyone who has been to our house and had it thrust upon them for their opinion. According to the press information, “The rhythm of the sounds increases incrementally as the pregnancy progresses. The BabyPlus sonic pattern introduces your child to a sequential learning process, built upon the natural rhythms of their own environment.” It’s supposed to help them distinguish between the sounds of the mothers heart and other sounds, thus giving the “learning process” a jump start. Doesn’t hearing the mother’s heartbeat in contrast to kids playing, the television blaring & the dishwasher rumbling do the same thing? Why does everything have to be “scientific?” (Which, I’m sure you know, means absolutely nothing.) (And, I have to disclose, my first degree was in psychology with a strong emphasis in both brain plasticity and child development so I do kind of know what I’m talking about.
“The BabyPlus lessons are designed to be played for 1 hour twice a day.” Do you have two spare hours on your hands to sit with this thing around your belly? Perhaps if you’re in your first pregnancy, but certainly not if you have more children to parent. And if you’re a working parent I beg you - please do not wear this thing in public. You’ll look like a moron. (And it’s not all that comfortable either.)
“BabyPlus is not a toy — it is a profound educational tool, and the first step in your child’s lifelong cognitive development.” What scares me about products like this is that they (a) can make a less confident or less educated parent spend their hard earned money on something that’s not necessary or (b) can make parents who can’t afford it feel like their child is going to be missing out on something important (which they certainly are not). The entire prenatal/baby IQ increasing industry is a joke. And not a funny one. It makes me sad. By the way, BabyPlus is $149 USD. Think of what else you could buy with that.
The tagline for the BabyPlus system is “You’re never too young to learn. (In fact, you don’t even have to be born!)” We wholeheartedly agree with this, but would add “It happens naturally. Don’t waste your money or your time on propaganda that tries, hopefully unsuccessfully, to make you feel like you’re cheating your child if you don’t buy it. All your child really needs is your love, your respect and your time.”
That said, if you really want to try this product I am happy to mail someone the sample. Just email theopinionatedparent@gmail.com with BabyPlus in the subject line. I’ll choose one reader using random.org and it’s yours. I’d also love to hear what you think about this product and the whole related industry, even if you don’t want to enter. The actual contest closes Monday 8/6/07 at midnight MST but I’ll always read your emails & opinions! Edited to add: Thanks to everyone who’s been sending emails! It’s great to see we’re not alone in our opinionated-ness. (I know that’s not a word…) Congratulations Jayna!